TikTok vs Instagram Reels vs YouTube Shorts: Where to Start in 2025

Everyone asks the wrong question: “Which platform should I be on?”

The right question is: “Which platform will actually drive business results for my industry?”

After testing all three with 100+ clients across 55+ industries, here’s what the data really says.

TikTok: The Discovery Engine

Best for: Service-based businesses, younger audiences (18–28), and brand awareness.

Average results:

• Reach: 3–5x higher than other platforms

• Engagement: 8–12% (highest)

• Lead quality: Low (lots of tire-kickers)

• Conversion rate: 2–4% (lowest)

The reality: TikTok gets you seen, but not necessarily hired.

One personal trainer hit 2.3M views, 847 inquiries, and closed 12 clients.
An immigration lawyer hit 400K views, 156 inquiries, and closed 3.

TikTok math: High volume, low conversion. Great for reach, not for ROI.

Instagram Reels: The Relationship Builder

Best for: Visual businesses, professional services, and established brands.
Average results:

• Reach: Moderate but consistent

• Engagement: 4–7%

• Lead quality: High

• Conversion rate: 8–15% (strongest)

The reality: Instagram builds relationships that convert.
The same trainer’s identical content on Instagram did 180K views, 89 inquiries, and 23 closed clients.
The lawyer’s Reels hit 95K views, 34 inquiries, and 8 closed clients.

Instagram math: Lower volume, higher conversion. Best for steady growth and leads.
+ Meta Ads Access.

YouTube Shorts: The Authority Platform

Best for: Educational content, B2B services, and long-term growth.
Average results:

• Reach: Slowest to start

• Engagement: 3–6%

• Lead quality: Highest

• Conversion rate: 12–25%

The reality: YouTube builds authority that lasts.
A business consultant’s Shorts averaged 15K views, generated 12 inquiries per month, and closed 8 clients.
A financial advisor averaged 8K views, 6 inquiries, and 4 clients at $50K+ each.
YouTube math: Lowest volume, highest value. Best for premium and long-term positioning.

The Platform Decision Framework

If you’re starting from zero: Instagram Reels

• Best balance of reach and conversion

• Easiest to build momentum

If you want maximum exposure: TikTok

• Highest viral potential

• Younger demographic

If you sell high-ticket services: YouTube Shorts/Long Form (Ideally pair with IG)

• Most educated audience

• Best long-term ROI

If you’re B2B: Instagram first, YouTube second

If you’re B2C: TikTok first, Instagram second

Platform Strategies That Work

TikTok: Use trends, fast hooks, and entertainment to boost reach.

Instagram Reels: Focus on value, authority, and clear CTAs.

YouTube Shorts: Teach, use searchable titles, and build series.

The best platform isn’t the one that’s popular. It’s the one where your ideal clients actually spend time and take action.

TikTok gets you famous.
Instagram gets you clients.
YouTube gets you authority.

The most successful businesses we work with start on Instagram, prove the concept, then expand to TikTok for reach and YouTube for authority.

Don’t chase platforms. Chase results.

My Offers:

Content Machine: We’ll create you 90 pieces of short form content and setup/build your Meta Ads (Done For You)

Funnel Build Out for Paid Advertising: We’ll Build you a Paid ads funnel from start to finish.

View Case Studies

Areeb Mirza’s YouTube Channel